News

This article in the Irish Times is interesting and I agree with some but not all of it. It is difficult to generalise as every single case involving allegations of misbehaviour, domestic violence and/or parental alienation need very careful investigation. There are competing rights of all involved and it is up to the Court in each case to resolve the dispute. This is exceptionally difficult. It is important to remember that those who do the reports for the Court are subject to cross examination on their report and the Judge is not obliged to follow the report and retains discretion. It is an area that needs close examination, resources and reform. 

This article in the Irish Times is interesting and I agree with some but not all of it. It is difficult to generalise as every single case involving allegations of misbehaviour, domestic violence and/or parental alienation need very careful investigation. There are competing rights of all involved and it is up to the Court in each case to resolve the dispute. This is exceptionally difficult. It is important to remember that those who do the reports for the Court are subject to cross examination on their report and the Judge is not obliged to follow the report and retains discretion. It is an area that needs close examination, resources and reform.